Welcome to Joe's Original Italian Pizza
At Joe's Original Italian Pizza, we embrace the heart and soul of authentic Italian cuisine. Nestled in Lewistown, PA, our restaurant transforms classic recipes into memorable experiences, warm hospitality, and a welcoming atmosphere. From fresh-baked bread to loaded pizzas, each dish is crafted with care, ensuring delight in every bite. Families and friends gather here, savoring hearty meals while enjoying the relaxing ambiance. Customer testimonials reflect our commitment to excellent service and quality ingredients, making us a beloved spot for locals. Whether dining in, taking out, or catered gatherings, Joe's is where great food and community unite. Join us on this delicious journey!
Joe's Original Italian Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
While camped at waterside campground we thought let's try some local pizza. It was very good.
I don't normally write reviews, but I was super impressed with the service at this location today. I stopped in for lunch with my parents and 5-month-old, and we were warmly welcomed and seated quickly. I have lived in a city for quite some time, and I'm always nervous about bringing a baby into a restaurant - especially during the lunch rush! The staff was accommodating, the food was delicious (and fast), and the overall feel was "homey". Very appreciated. Thank you!
Ordered meals for 6 to go. Service taking the order and paying the bill was super nice and excellent. We did not eat inside but the ambience was quaint for a relatively small Italian restaurant. Definitely recommend the hot ham and cheese subs. Be sure to request plastic wear, napkins, ranch, ketchup, if you want it. Only downside was it was so busy with other takeout orders it was hard to get into the door!
We order from here all the time .... food is always great. Staff is always friendly and accommodating. Definitely recommend giving them a try !!!
Oh my gosh I love love love this place there Wally ledge. Can you feed me for three days and oh so delicious that fresh baked bread makes a fat girls dream and I'm allowed to say that because trust me I'm a fat girl anyway completely awesome really nice wait staff as well, one guy in there is not too nice, but he stays in the back for the most part so you don't deal with him other than that place is a pretty good place.
Yet another great experience at Joe's! Family came in from out of town. We had a larger party and the waitress was extremely accommodating. The tables were moved around to make it work. She was perfect in conversation with all of us and handled the kids perfectly. If you knew my kids, you would know that takes patience. So with orders taken, it wasn't long for the food to arrive. Damn was it as great as always. Perfect OIP pizza New York style. Perfect OIP subs. These guys do it right. Even for a smaller shop. Perfect service. Perfect food. Perfect sub/pizza shop experience. Always a local favorite for me. The last bastion or the Joe and Frank style OIP food.
Location
-
46 Supercenter Plaza Dr Lewistown, PA 17044 Hotline: (717) 248-1611
Welcome to Joe's Original Italian Pizza, a charming slice of Italy nestled in Lewistown, Pennsylvania. Located conveniently at 46 Supercenter Plaza Dr, this delightful eatery is more than just a pizza joint—it's a destination for families, friends, and pizza lovers alike.
At Joe's, you can experience the true essence of Italian cuisine, delivered with a warm and inviting atmosphere. Whether you're looking to savor a meal in-house, or prefer the convenience of takeout or delivery, Joe's has you covered. The restaurant offers a cozy setting that is quiet and good for groups, making it an excellent choice for gatherings—small or large. Kids are more than welcome, and the dedicated staff ensures that every visitor feels right at home.
- Takes Reservations
- Offers Takeout and Delivery
- Accepts Credit Cards
- Private Lot Parking
- Beer & Wine Only
- Outdoor Seating
- Bike Parking
Many satisfied customers have shared their thoughts on Joe’s. One happy diner, Ron B., raved, "While camped at waterside campground, we thought let's try some local pizza. It was very good." This sentiment is echoed by Jill D., who appreciated how “the staff was accommodating, the food delicious (and fast),” especially during a bustling lunch hour. These reviews emphasize the respectable service and quality that Joe’s delivers consistently.
The menu boasts a variety of aromatic dishes, with the hot ham and cheese subs coming highly recommended. As William H. noted, “the service taking the order and paying the bill was super nice and excellent.” Patrons are encouraged to tailor their takeout experiences by requesting necessary items like plastic ware and sauces—a small detail that enhances the overall experience.
While some diners note an occasional rush during busy periods, the comforting ambiance and delectable offerings at Joe's Original Italian Pizza remain constant draws. Chantra G. captures the spirit of the restaurant perfectly, declaring, “Oh my gosh I love love love this place there Wally ledge.” The inclusion of fresh-baked bread adds an artisanal touch that appeals to all, no matter their palate preferences.
If you're in the area, Joe's Original Italian Pizza promises a culinary journey where every dish carries the heart of Italian tradition. The welcoming atmosphere, attentive service, and mouthwatering food create a wonderful dining experience perfect for any occasion. Don't miss out—visit or call them today at (717) 248-1611 to explore the delicious offerings that await you!
